Vilém Flusser’s “Towards a Philosophy of Photography”: An Analysis of Apparatus and Program
To read this book is to learn to examine the computation and rules behind every photograph with a “systems eye.”
The Czech-born philosopher Vilém Flusser published this book in German in 1983 (Für eine Philosophie der Fotografie), introducing core concepts like the “technical image,” “apparatus,” and “program.” Through a series of dense, short chapters, the book attempts to build a media philosophy that can penetrate the operations of the camera and the image-making institution. It is not a history or a technical guide, but an analysis of the power structure between the apparatus, the program, and the operator.
Core Concepts: Apparatus, Program, and Functionary
Flusser’s argument unfolds along four primary paths:
1. Technical Image ≠ Traditional Image: Images as “Projections of Concepts”
Flusser distinguishes traditional, hand-made images from “technical images” (those generated by an apparatus, like a camera or computer). The technical image does not directly reflect the world; rather, it compresses scientific and conceptual texts into a visible surface. It is an “image of texts (theories).” Significance: We no longer confront the world directly, but confront images that have been pre-coded by theory and technology.
2. The Apparatus and the Program: The Photographer as “Functionary”
The camera is a black box with closed rules. Its “program” pre-determines the space of possible images that can be produced. The photographer mostly operates as a user, playing within the possibilities allowed by the program, and is therefore more of a “functionary” of the apparatus. Conclusion: The look of a photograph is decided first by the program; human creativity is often enveloped within the program’s decision tree.
3. “Playing Against” the Apparatus: Generating Information Through Improbability
In a world dominated by programs, the vast majority of images are redundant (predictable, reproducible). A valuable photograph—one with “information”—is produced when one plays against the tendencies of the program. It makes an improbable or unfamiliar combination appear. The creative strategy thus becomes: understand the rules of the apparatus, then design a deviation to play for an accident on the edge of those rules.
4. The Post-Alphabetical World and Politics: Distribution, Code, and Dialogue
Technical images shift society from a “text-centric” to an “image-centric” model, where a sense of history is replaced by real-time circulation. Power is held by those who write, maintain, and control the programs and distribution channels. However, Flusser suggests that if interactive, “telematic” (dialogical) networks can be established, technical images might also foster decentralized public exchange.
Value and Impact: A Critical Tool for the Post-Digital Age
The enduring value of Flusser’s philosophy can be understood on two levels:
- Value as Method and Tool: The book provides a three-key toolkit for production: (a) Apparatus analysis: first asking what the black box’s rules are; (b) Program-consciousness: identifying how the “options tree” prefigures aesthetics; (c) Counter-operation: using an “anti-program” strategy to create information and critique.
- Long-Term Impact: Flusser’s diagnosis of the “apparatus/program” became the core vocabulary of the post-digital era. In an age of algorithms, platforms, and smartphone photography, his insights are a direct critical tool for “preset filters” and “recommendation systems.” It complements Crary’s history of the observer (how the body is shaped by instruments) and provides a theoretical horizon for Manovich’s digital linguistics and Steyerl’s politics of the poor image.
This book reminds us that to understand a photograph, we must look not just at the picture, but at the program that determined what could be made visible.
コメント